Noam Chomsky vs Philip Lieberman, prof, Brown.edu

Young-Won Kim   Fri Apr 30, 2010 9:48 am GMT
Comparative phonetics
http://voicespec.com/board.cgi?id=test1
http://voicespec.com/

http://voicespec.com/board.cgi?id=test2&action=view&gul=65&page=1&go_cnt=0 ,

1. Philip Lieberman, prof. Brown.edu replied me
http://www.cog.brown.edu/people_lieberman_personal.htm ,
that Noam Chomsky had already presented the presumption(s) similar to my below writing:

"The vocabularies and grammar(s)/etc. of all (modern and Inca/Maya-like-disappeared-antique) languages (including their dialects) are already stored in human brain at birth (and now in your/my brains also). That is, I mean not that POTENTIAL to learn any language is there as an innate HUMAN ABILITY, but that your/my brain now has the vocabularies and grammar(s)/etc. of Korean language, Chinese, Japanese, English, German, French, etc."

2. Philip Lieberman, prof. Brown.edu agrees that any vowel of [a, e, i, o, u, etc.] can be spoken/pronounced while fixing the tongue in one place/position, without movement.
But IPA (and most phonetics professors) speak different story, as you know.

For details, click/visit
http://voicespec.com/board.cgi?id=test2&action=view&gul=65&page=1&go_cnt=0 ,


----- Original Message -----
From: "ygwnkm" <ygwnkm@yahoo.co.kr>
To: <Philip_Lieberman@brown.edu>
Sent:
Subject: Linguistics / phonetics, NEWS

Believe (it) or not, the vocabularies and grammar(s)/etc. of all (modern and Inca/Maya-like-disappeared-antique) languages (including their dialects) are already stored in human brain at birth (and now in your/my brains also). That is, I mean not that POTENTIAL to learn any language is there as an innate HUMAN ABILITY, but that your/my brain now has the vocabularies and grammar(s)/etc. of Korean language, Chinese, Japanese, English, German, French, etc. We only do not have effective/efficient experience/chance to use them.

If you study/know (not fake but) genuine phonetics (phonology or the likes), you can take out words/grammars/etc. of various languages from your brain; since knowledge/information in the brain is expressed in the form of voice (or thought/idea/concept/etc.)

I have world-firstly found how to take out words/grammars/etc. of various languages from the brain and speaking postures/etc. Click below.

http://voicespec.com/board.cgi?id=test2&action=view&gul=47&page=1&go_cnt=0
http://voicespec.com/board.cgi?id=test3&action=view&gul=68-1&page=1&go_cnt=0

Comparative phonetics
http://voicespec.com/board.cgi?id=test1
http://voicespec.com/

Young-Won Kim
ygwnkm@yahoo.co.kr , ygwnkm@hotmail.com ,
feati   Fri Apr 30, 2010 2:51 pm GMT
----- Original Message -----
From: "Philip Lieberman" < Philip_Lieberman@brown.edu>
To: "ygwnkm" < ygwnkm@yahoo.co.kr>
Sent: Wednesday, March 04, 2009 1:28 PM
Subject: Re: Language/linguistics & phonetics

> Breaking news - this is nonsense.
>
> Philip Lieberman


//////////////////////


----- Original Message -----
From: "Philip Lieberman" < Philip_Lieberman@brown.edu>
To: "ygwnkm" < ygwnkm@yahoo.co.kr>
Sent: Thursday, May 21, 2009 8:20 PM
Subject: Re: Philip Lieberman, fred m. seed professor, Brown.edu/5

> [i] and [u] can not be produced with the same tongue position.


////////////////////////


----- Original Message -----
From: "Philip Lieberman" < Philip_Lieberman@brown.edu>
To: "ygwnkm" < ygwnkm@yahoo.co.kr>
Sent: Friday, May 22, 2009 3:31 AM
Subject: Re: Philip Lieberman, fred m. seed professor, Brown.edu/6

> STOP EMAILING ME and do not forward any of your emails to or from me.
>
> PL


/////////////////////////