How to pronounce wonder and wander

vanyatka   Sun Jan 07, 2007 3:54 pm GMT
Hi, everyone

As dictionaries say "to wonder" should be pronounced like /w^nder/, while "to wander" like /wOnder/. Quite often I hear people say /wOnder/ (meaning ramble) when they actually mean /w^nder/ - to think.

Here is the example:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vEfLUl58bVY

According to dictionaries it should be /w^nder/, but I clearly hear /wOnder/...

So, my question is, how to say "to wonder" (think), properly?
Thank you,
Lazar   Sun Jan 07, 2007 4:11 pm GMT
The dictionaries are correct. In American English, they are:

wonder ["wVnd@`]
wander ["wAnd@`]

And in Southern British English, they are:

wonder ["wVnd@]
wander ["wQnd@]

<<Quite often I hear people say /wOnder/ (meaning ramble) when they actually mean /w^nder/ - to think.>>

I don't recall ever hearing that.

<<According to dictionaries it should be /w^nder/, but I clearly hear /wOnder/...>>

To my ears, he's clearly saying ["wVnd@`].

<<So, my question is, how to say "to wonder" (think), properly?>>

As far as I know, most people (including me) pronounce it to rhyme with "under" or "plunder".
vanyatka   Sun Jan 07, 2007 4:52 pm GMT
Thanks for your reply, Lazar
I got your point, I must understand now that the problem lies in my hearing.

Can you confirm though, that to your ears Del Shannon sounds like
http://education.yahoo.com/reference/dictionary/entry/wonder

And nothing like
http://education.yahoo.com/reference/dictionary/entry/wander

Because to me, the opposite is true.
Thank you
Mike   Sun Jan 07, 2007 5:19 pm GMT
I have /wAnd@`/ and /wVnd@`/. They're clearly different.
Lazar   Sun Jan 07, 2007 5:56 pm GMT
<<Can you confirm though, that to your ears Del Shannon sounds like...And nothing like...Because to me, the opposite is true.>>

It sounds to me like he's saying ["wVnd@`]. It sounds just the same as the vowel he uses in "love" and "done".
vanyatka   Sun Jan 07, 2007 6:39 pm GMT
<< I have /wAnd@`/ and /wVnd@`/. They're clearly different >>

Stop, what is 'V' sound?

<< It sounds to me like he's saying ["wVnd@`]. It sounds just the same as the vowel he uses in "love" and "done" >>

Thanks. For me it is more like 'ponder' or 'yonder'. (in British pronunciation)
Lazar   Sun Jan 07, 2007 6:56 pm GMT
<<Stop, what is 'V' sound?>>

Mike and I are using the phonetic alphabet called X-SAMPA. You can see what all the symbols mean here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-SAMPA . The symbol [V] represents the vowel sound in words like "cut" and "strut".
vanyatka   Sun Jan 07, 2007 7:28 pm GMT
<< I have /wAnd@`/ and /wVnd@`/. They're clearly different >>

For you, Del Shannon also sings /wVnder/?
Travis   Mon Jan 08, 2007 12:41 am GMT
>>The dictionaries are correct. In American English, they are:

wonder ["wVnd@`]
wander ["wAnd@`]

And in Southern British English, they are:

wonder ["wVnd@]
wander ["wQnd@]<<

I assume you mean General American, of course, as at least here they are:

wonder ["wV~:ndR=]
wander ['wQ~:ndR=]

Ignoring the marking of long nasal vowels, which is more just a difference in transcription than in that actually being transcribed, this is superficially more like the Southern English English pattern with respect to the vowels used. Such is superficial, though, because this [Q] does not actually directly correspond to historical /Q/ but is due to [wQ] -> [wO] (rather than [wQ] -> [wA]) -> [wQ] (thanks to the general lowering of [O] -> [Q] when not before /r/).
Lazar   Mon Jan 08, 2007 1:06 am GMT
<<I assume you mean General American, of course,...>

Yes, I meant General American. In my own New England dialect, I also pronounce "wander" as ["wQnd@`]. ;-)
Jim   Tue Jan 09, 2007 2:41 am GMT
["w6n.d@]
["wOn.d@]