A French question

a quester   Mon May 04, 2009 4:35 pm GMT
If a French person, never having encountered the word "oasis" (a child for example), suddenly happens to see that word, will he intuitively know that it's feminine?
french person   Mon May 04, 2009 4:40 pm GMT
yes.
jio   Mon May 04, 2009 5:01 pm GMT
Non, pas du tout
greg   Mon May 04, 2009 5:41 pm GMT
Non, il n'y aucun moyen de "découvrir" le genre grammatical de <oasis> autrement que par l'imitation de celui qui vient de prononcer ce mot. Sinon, il y a bien sûr les dictionnaires pour ceux qui hésitent.


Et les hésitants sont d'ailleurs nombreux :

<une oasis> → 16 %
*<un oasis> → 84 %.


Mais :

<une oasis de verdure> → 89 %
*<un oasis de verdure> → 11 %

<une oasis saharienne> → 91 %
*<un oasis saharien> → 9 %

<oasis saharienne> → 93 %
*<oasis saharien> → 7 %

<oasis providentielle> → 97 %
*<oasis providentiel> → 3 %

<une oasis providentielle> → 100 %
*<un oasis providentiel> → 0 %
guest guest   Mon May 04, 2009 6:05 pm GMT
" If a French person, never having encountered the word "oasis" (a child for example), suddenly happens to see that word, will he intuitively know that it's feminine? "


usually, when we encounter a word, we encounter it in its context: in a sentence, writed or pronounced: that is to say always linked with "le" or "la". It is the article that give us the idea that a word is masculine or feminine.

There are some exceptions, for exemple the words that began with a vowel. because in this case we use " l' " in both feminine or masculine case. In that situation it is the whole sentence that helps to know the gender: if a child hear "L'éléphant est grand", he will know that "Elephant" is masculine, because of "grand" and not "grande".