Why are Japanese so bad at pronouncing english?

Franco   Sun Jun 17, 2007 3:49 am GMT
Is it because their katakana doesnt allow correct pronunciation to be represented or is it because they cannot make the sounds well physically?
Matthew   Sun Jun 17, 2007 4:13 am GMT
It's the same reason speakers of any language develop accents: the sounds are different. Japanese requires a vowel to come after every consonant besides N, and many of the consonants of English don't exist. It's a radical change for a native Japanese speaker whose mouth is not trained to make those changes to English. With practice, though, everyone can lose their accent in any language.
furrykef   Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:18 am GMT
It is because of their language's limited phonology. Katakana being unable to accurately represent English speech is merely a reflection of that; it is a symptom, not the cause.

If you had to speak a language like Polish where many consonants are clustered together in ways that are alien to English and Spanish speakers, you'd probably have crappy pronunciation, too.

- Kef
Franco   Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:22 am GMT
Gracias por las respuestas, es muy interesante.

<<If you had to speak a language like Polish where many consonants are clustered together in ways that are alien to English and Spanish speakers, you'd probably have crappy pronunciation, too>>

Creo que tendría pronunciación excelente, porque todo lo que toco se convierta en oro. Lol!